Skip to main content

.45-70 Gov't - The Old War Horse

.45-70 Gov't - The Old War Horse
Photo Courtesy of MidwayUSA
On the campus of my old college, Kansas University, in an old but imposing building, there is a natural history museum. In this quiet place you can visit Comanche, favorite horse of Capt. Myles Keogh of the Seventh Cavalry. Found on the battlefield with numerous wounds, Comanche was the only known survivor of Custer’s column at the Little Big Horn. The last rifle shots this horse heard fired in anger, at least from his side, were on June 25, 1876, from carbines chambered to the .45-70. Amazingly, the .45-70 remains among our most popular centerfire cartridges.

“Most popular”? You might question this, but in current sales figures I’ve seen—whether for rifles, ammo,or reloading dies—the .45-70 is right up there. In any recent data, you will usually find, in various order, .223, .22-250, .243, .270, .308, .30-06, .300 Win. Mag., 6.5 Creedmoor, maybe the 7mm-08 and .30-30. But you will also usually see the venerable .45-70.

Not long ago I characterized the .45-70 as a short-range cartridge and immediately drew letters from several shooters who enjoy ringing long-range steel with their .45-70s. You bet you can.

In 1866 we adopted the .50-70, among the first centerfire cartridges, in the Allin-conversion trapdoor Springfield. In 1873 we switched to the lighter, faster .45-70-405, the latter number denoting a 405-grain bullet. In 1879 we tested a heavier 500-grain bullet and found it to be better at extreme range: The heavier bullet was found effective to 3,350 yards, about 1.75 miles. The .45-70-500 was adopted in the beefed-up 1884 Springfield. Because of brutal recoil in carbines, lighter loads (.45-55) were issued to cavalry.

The accuracy standard for the trapdoor Springfield was a four-inch group at 100 yards. This translates to more than 11 feet at 3,350 yards. The intent was for volley-fire against massed troops. Whether this was ever attempted at such range I have no idea, but in the Spanish-American War, when the Army should have had .30-40 Krags and the Navy and Marines should have had the 6mm Lee Navy, a lot of our troops still had trapdoor Springfields.

There are marvelous accounts, mostly from the Philippines, of our troops doing effective sniping with .45-70s well beyond 1,000 yards. They didn’t use laser rangefinders, nor did they twist their turrets or use hashmarks in scope reticles. They used ladder sights, and like artillery, they registered fire on distant, unoccupied positions and trail junctions, and when hapless Spaniards appeared they potted them with disconcerting regularity.

Whether the loads used were the .45-70-405 or .45-70-500 doesn’t seem to be recorded—it was probably the latter—but it proves Boddington’s Ballistic Law: At some distance, with any cartridge, trajectory is just a number, and if you know the number you can make hits.

That said, I hold to my premise that, at least as a hunting cartridge, the .45-70 is a short to, at best, very medium-range cartridge. It was introduced 15 years before the first smokeless powder cartridge—20 years before the first American smokeless cartridge—so I find it fabulous that it’s not just still with us but still popular.

Thing is, the grand old .45-70 works. The equation that derives foot-pounds, our most common measure of projectile power, requires the square of velocity, while bullet weight and frontal area are taken as is. Foot-pounds are real and scientific. Alternate theories such as momentum (Keith’s pounds-feet) and Taylor’s “Knock-Out” values are not as rooted in hard science, but I still think we’re missing something.

Despite slow velocities and thus modest foot-pound yields, large-caliber bullets hit hard. It’s probably an issue of energy transfer, which has never been properly quantified. Whatever the reason, close-cover whitetail hunters know, as do black bear and wild hog hunters, that the .45-70 anchors game.

Although loaded with smokeless powder for a century, standard factory.45-70 loads are mild in case they might be used in trapdoor Springfields. While the trapdoor was a clever post-Civil War expedient, it is not a strong action. These days many of us use light-for-caliber bullets, 250 grains up to 300 grains. They’re a lot faster without increased pressure, flattening the trajectory (at least to medium ranges). With the great bullets we have today, this doesn’t matter on deer and probably doesn’t matter much on black bears and boars. Frontal area does matter, and even with lighter bullets the .45-70 is a thumper.

For larger game I’m pretty sure you’re better off to forget about velocity and go back to the 19th-century formula. You still have the hard-hitting frontal area, and bullet weight gives you penetration. In the late 1870s the .45-70 was the most available cartridge on the Great Plains, and I suspect it accounted for a lot more bison than the sexier Sharps cartridges. In Africa and India the .577/.450 Martini Henry, with similar ballistics to the .45-70, was widely used on large game well into the 20th century.

Hard-cast bullets penetrate extremely well at .45-70 velocities. At close range it wouldn’t bother me to tackle a big bear or a Cape buffalo with a standard 405-grain .45-70 load at just below 1,400 fps. The energy yield isn’t impressive, but between frontal area and penetration—coupled with good shot placement—it would do fine.

Fortunately, there are stronger actions that can handle more, and you can handload accordingly. Most loading manuals offer “grades” of loading data: trapdoor Springfields, 95 Marlins and 86 Winchesters, and the Ruger No. 1. With the lever actions you can easily get a 400-grain bullet over 1,800 fps, and now we’re talking business. With the Ruger No. 1 and other strong falling blocks, you run out of case capacity before pressure becomes an issue, but you can come close to the .458 Win. Mag.

Commercial loads are another option. For decades Garrett has offered ascending levels of .45-70 loads, from trapdoor Springfield to Ruger No. 1. Its super-hard-cast flat-point bullets are great for both impact and penetration.

Mind you, I am not a .45-70 freak. I don’t push the range envelope with them, and although I’ve taken lever actions and single-shots to Africa, none have yet been .45-70s. But I admire the cartridge and always have a couple of .45-70 rifles on hand, even though for a long time I thought, incorrectly, it was sort of a specialized cartridge. Until recently, I didn’t realize it was so generally popular. I think that’s marvelous—a ghost from the Old West that’s not only still with us but also still useful.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Ruger Launches New American Rifle Predator in 6.5 Grendel

Ruger Launches New American Rifle Predator in 6.5 Grendel

OSG's Lynn Burkhead and Ruger's Matt WIlson kick off SHOT Show 2018 by taking a look at the Ruger Predator.

RS Sako Finnlight II

RS Sako Finnlight II

The new Sako Finnlight II sports an innovative stock and Cerakote metal paired with the terrific 85 action.

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Tom Beckstrand and Neal Emery of Hornady highlight the 6MM Creedmoor ammo.

Steyr Arms Announces Sniper Rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor

Steyr Arms Announces Sniper Rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor

Scott O'Brien from Steyr Arms sat down with Michael Bane at SHOT Show 2018 to take a look at Steyr's new tactical heavy barrel sniper rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The road to the famous Remington 700 rifle was paved with classics like the models 725 and 30s.Before the Remington 700 Historical

Before the Remington 700

Payton Miller - August 20, 2020

The road to the famous Remington 700 rifle was paved with classics like the models 725 and 30s.

A .22LR rimfire rifle is a must-own for any gun owner, and these six bolt-action rimfire rifles give shooters a variety of offerings to choose from.6 Great Rimfire Bolt-Action Rifles Rimfire

6 Great Rimfire Bolt-Action Rifles

Jeff John - July 22, 2020

A .22LR rimfire rifle is a must-own for any gun owner, and these six bolt-action rimfire...

You're only as good as your weakest link; heed these to tips to make sure your shooting skills don't hinder your rifle's accuracy potentialHow to Shoot Your Best from a Benchrest Shooting Tips

How to Shoot Your Best from a Benchrest

Keith Wood - August 05, 2014

You're only as good as your weakest link; heed these to tips to make sure your shooting skills...

The author takes stock of rimfire rifles he's known and loved..22 Memory Lane Ammo

.22 Memory Lane

J. Scott Rupp - January 04, 2019

The author takes stock of rimfire rifles he's known and loved.

See More Trending Articles

More Ammo

The .222 Rem. is not only a classic round. It also spawned an entire family of cartridges..222 Remington Rifle Cartridge – Family Portrait Ammo

.222 Remington Rifle Cartridge – Family Portrait

Layne Simpson - July 24, 2020

The .222 Rem. is not only a classic round. It also spawned an entire family of cartridges.

Craig Boddington gives his top cartridge choices from 6mm to .45 for those who think “biggest, fastest” isn't all it's cracked up to be.Best Non-Magnum Rifle Cartridges Available Ammo

Best Non-Magnum Rifle Cartridges Available

Craig Boddington - December 18, 2020

Craig Boddington gives his top cartridge choices from 6mm to .45 for those who think “biggest,...

Listed by caliber, here's a look at what big game rifle cartridges are trending upward, and which are not.Top Big Game Rifle Cartridges by Caliber Ammo

Top Big Game Rifle Cartridges by Caliber

J. Scott Rupp - July 07, 2020

Listed by caliber, here's a look at what big game rifle cartridges are trending upward, and...

This cartridge clash between the .45-70 Gov't and .450 Bushmaster is less about the minute details of the cartridge and more about your personal taste in firearms..45-70 vs .450 Bushmaster — Cartridge Clash Ammo

.45-70 vs .450 Bushmaster — Cartridge Clash

Brad Fitzpatrick - May 21, 2020

This cartridge clash between the .45-70 Gov't and .450 Bushmaster is less about the minute...

See More Ammo

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the RifleShooter App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All RifleShooter subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now