The Hunting Rifle

The Hunting Rifle

In 1970, as he neared the end of his career at Outdoor Life, Jack O'Connor wrote a book called simply The Hunting Rifle.

In 1970, as he neared the end of his career at Outdoor Life, Jack O'Connor wrote a book called simply The Hunting Rifle. Years later, as I ran my eye down the bookshelf, past all the volumes of O'Connor's work, I found it puzzling that he would devote an entire book to a subject that I thought was rather obvious. No more.

As the rifle world moves in several directions at once, all of them undesirable, I see exactly what motivated O'Connor to write that book 40 years ago, and wonder what he would think if he could see the stuff being produced now.


Don't misunderstand. There are some fine rifles being made today, and not all of them are custom jobs. But there are also some real disasters--rifles that are suitable for hunting the way a cow is suitable to run the Kentucky Derby.



Onto these rifles we are putting scopes that are more suitable for studying the four moons of Jupiter, that have illuminated reticles you could read by, and weigh as much as the rifle itself.

So what is a good hunting rifle? Basically, it is no different today than it was in O'Connor's era.


The hunting rifle should be light enough to carry comfortably all day, yet heavy enough for steady shooting and to tame the recoil; it should be handy enough for quick response, and to shoot from odd, hurried positions; it should be sufficiently accurate for its purpose at ethical ranges; it should be powerful enough to kill the intended game cleanly even when everything goes wrong, not when everything goes just right. Most of all, no single feature mentioned above should be over-emphasized to the detriment of the other desirable attributes.


Now I would add a couple of specifics: One, it absolutely must have a three-position safety, or a two-position safety that pulls the striker back off the sear and locks the bolt shut. A huge percentage of semi-custom hunting rifles today are based on the Remington 700 action, for which it is possible to get an after-market shroud with such a safety. The fact that so many others stick with the execrable two-position Remington safety that allows the bolt to pop open just shows that very few of the manufacturers do any real hunting themselves, or use their own product doing it.

Push-feed versus controlled feed? It could go either way. There are good ones and bad ones of each type. I prefer the Mauser-type controlled feed but I'm not a fanatic.

The Winchester 94, while hardly fashionable today, is one of the finest pure hunting rifles ever made--ergonomically excellent, accurate enough and powerful enough out to 200 yards, which is the extreme one would shoot using its iron sights or receiver sight.

And, of course, there are the great double rifles. They are nothing but hunting rifles and superb for their intended purpose. Into this group you could also lump almost every single-shot mountain rifle ever to come out of England or Central Europe.

I know a fellow who owns a 7mm Remington Magnum in a sort of target configuration. Heavy barrel, bulky stock. Fitted on this thing are a bipod; a bulky, heavy, cobra-style sling; and a 6-18x50 riflescope.

It weighs about five kilograms. Aside from the weight, all the junk on it makes it uncomfortable to carry for even a short distance, much less all day. It is noisy, with all its extraneous bits clanking against each other. Its owner is an American whitetail hunter, but it is a monstrously unsuitable whitetail rifle, and I can think of very few situations in Africa where it would be anything but lousy.

If the owner of this rifle ever got out and walked while hunting, carrying his rifle up and down real mountains, or slung under his chest crawling through the underbrush, he would see how poor it really is. Alas, he doesn't, and he won't.

There are practical aspects to a good hunting rifle that only become apparent when you are in the field, with the rifle, hour after hour, carrying it, slinging it on your shoulder, getting in and out of vehicles, loading and unloading it, using it as an alpenstock or balancing pole on steep slopes. Only then do you see how it carries, what sharp edges dig into you, how quiet it is in operation. Only then do you see if it has a comfortable balance point that will allow you to carry it for mile after mile.

A few makers say they care about these ergonomic fine points, and a few even produce rifles that suggest they mean what they say. But most rifles are produced by engineers on the one hand who don't hunt or shoot, dictated to by marketing people who also don't hunt or shoot.

The engineers are in love with things they can measure--accuracy, velocity, energy--but accuracy and velocity, alone or together, do not make a hunting rifle. If they did, we would all be pushing wheelbarrows with benchrest rifles in them, setting up on hilltops and waiting for that big antelope to emerge a kilometer away.

If there is an African equivalent of the American deer hunter's Winchester 94 in .30-30, it is either the Mauser 93 in 7x57, or the British Lee-Enfield in .303. Even in a minimally sporterized state, both of those are excellent hunting rifles. They are accurate enough, and powerful enough, for the purpose; they are durable to a fault, easy to carry, and absolutely dependable. Both have shown an astonishing degree of accuracy over the past century in thousand-yard matches, but that's not really relevant.

When you think of it, there are really very few hunting situations in Africa today that could not be more than adequately handled by a sporterized 7x57, with iron sights, in the hands of a hunter who knows how to stalk and how to shoot under real hunting conditions. It's been true for a century, and it's true now.

Recommended for You

Some history and reloading recipes on five popular .17-caliber cartridges, including the .17 Ackley Hornet, .17 Hornady Hornet, .17 Mach IV, .17 Remington Fireball and .17 Remington. Reloading

.17-Caliber Reloading Data and History for 5 Cartridges

Layne Simpson - June 05, 2019

Some history and reloading recipes on five popular .17-caliber cartridges, including the .17...

Thompson/Center and S&W's Performance Center team up to build an entry-level long-range chassis rifle. Bolt-Action

Review: Performance Center-Thompson/Center LRR

Alfredo Rico - April 09, 2019

Thompson/Center and S&W's Performance Center team up to build an entry-level long-range...

The Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo combines high BCs with a forgiving bullet profile and promises versatile performance. Ammo

Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo

Brad Fitzpatrick - April 30, 2019

The Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo combines high BCs with a forgiving bullet profile and...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Tactical Solutions Introduces New X-Ring Takedown SBR Rifle

Tactical Solutions Introduces New X-Ring Takedown SBR Rifle

Keith Feeley of Tactical Solutions sat down with Michael Bane at SHOT Show 2018 to talk about the new X-Ring Takedown SBR .22LR rifle.

RS Sako Finnlight II

RS Sako Finnlight II

The new Sako Finnlight II sports an innovative stock and Cerakote metal paired with the terrific 85 action.

All About .300 Blackout

All About .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout is here to stay, and we take some time to look at new technology surrounding this cartridge. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

Gunsite's Ed Head reviews the Ruger American/Robar Scout Rifle. Bolt-Action

Review: Ruger American/Robar Scout Rifle

Ed Head - April 23, 2019

Gunsite's Ed Head reviews the Ruger American/Robar Scout Rifle.

Smith & Wesson's M&P15 SPORT II OR rifle with Crimson Trace CTS-103 optic will be on display at the Smith & Wesson Booth at the 2019 NRA Show. MSR

M&P15 SPORT II Rifle Available with CTS-103 Optic

Rifle Shooter Digital Staff - April 23, 2019

Smith & Wesson's M&P15 SPORT II OR rifle with Crimson Trace CTS-103 optic will be on display...

Browning's new X-Bolt Max Long Range rifle is an accurate rifle tailored for long range accuracy. Bolt-Action

Browning's New X-Bolt Max Long Range Rifle

Rifle Shooter Digital Staff - April 11, 2019

Browning's new X-Bolt Max Long Range rifle is an accurate rifle tailored for long range...

See More Stories

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.