Match-Grade Primers — Are They Worth It?

Jospeh von Benedikt takes a small test to see if match-grade primers really make a difference.

Match-Grade Primers — Are They Worth It?
Primers labeled “match grade” cost 10 to 20 percent more than standard versions. Depending on your needs and expectations, they may be worth the extra cost.

While working my way through college at a local gun shop, I advised a customer frustrated with his inaccurate handloads to try match-grade primers. He bought a 100 pack of Federal Gold Medal caps, and the next week he came back brimming with enthusiasm: “Changing primers turned my rifle from a two-inch gun to a three-quarter-inch gun,” he said.

I’ve always been the type to walk the extra mile for anything that might have an effect on performance, and I’ve always purchased match-grade primers. They’re only a few bucks more per 1,000, and the peace of mind I get by knowing I’m leaving no stone unturned in my search for precision makes the cost worth it.

But do match-grade primers really make a difference? To find out, I recently performed a comparison test with two different rifles.

The first was my old go-to Winchester Model 70 in .30-06. It was customized years ago by Hill Country Rifles and has a Lilja barrel. The second is my favorite PRS rifle, a GA Precision in 6mm Creedmoor with a Bartlein barrel.


For the .30-06, I loaded five different test batches of ammunition, all using Nosler cases charged with 55 grains of Reloder 16 and topped with 175-grain Barnes LRX bullets. The only difference was the Large Rifle primers, of which there were five different types: Federal 210 standard, Federal 210 Gold Medal, CCI No. 200 standard, CCI BR-2 benchrest-grade and Winchester WLR standard.


For the 6mm Creedmoor, I also loaded five batches. Each used new Peterson brass with Small Rifle primer pockets and charged with 40 grains of Reloder 16. I used Hornady 110-grain A-Tip bullets.

Like the .30-06 test loads, I used both standard and Gold Medal grade Federal primers, and standard and benchrest grade CCI primers. For the fifth test batch, I used Remington No. 6½ Small Rifle standard primers.

Each test batch consisted of 10 rounds, which I fired in two consecutive five-shot groups, clocking the full 10-round string using a LabRadar. Conditions at the range were questionable, with wind gusting to 12 mph and temperatures hovering at a finger-numbing 25 degrees. At least the barrels cooled quickly.

Results were a little unanticipated, although one difference emerged almost immediately. I started with the .30-06 because it needed to cool completely between five-shot groups. The Creedmoor’s heavy match barrel doesn’t and historically has grouped a bit tighter during the second five-shot group in a 10-round string.


Firing the .30-06 handloads with Winchester’s Large Rifle primers, I was disconcerted to find accuracy relatively poor, in excess of 1.5 m.o.a. Also, one of the 10 primers failed to fire, even though I hit it with three consecutive attempts.

With Federal’s standard-grade 210 primers, the rifle was immediately happier, grouping much more consistently. But to my surprise, the .30-06 displayed little difference in accuracy between the standard and Gold Medal grade primers.

In fact, in both cases the match-grade primers produced a slightly larger group-size average. However, the differences are within the potential variability of human and environmental influence.


I did observe that Federal’s primers—both grades—produced significantly smaller velocity extreme spread and standard deviation. This proved true with the 6mm Creedmoor as well. You can see the complete data on the accompanying chart.

Match-Grade-Primers
Notes: All groups fired at 100 yards. The .30-06 was fired from a Harris bipod and rear sandbag. The 6mm Creedmoor was fired from a Ckye bipod and rear sandbag. Velocities measured with a Labradar chronograph.

Adding up the velocity data, group sizes and observed anomalies with the .30-06, I had to conclude that aside from avoiding primers the rifle doesn’t like—in this case the Winchester Large Rifle—the rifle drew no advantage from using match-grade primers. From here on out, I’m going to be loading my .30-06 ammo with Federal standard 210 primers.

My tests with the 6mm Creedmoor told a different story. The Federal 205 Gold Medal primers produced a gratifyingly tight 13 fps extreme spread and just four fps standard deviation—small enough deviance to satisfy even the most particular long-range precision shooter.

Accuracy may have benefited too, but all five primer types produced accuracy averages within 0.15 inch of each other. That’s within my margin of error, particularly on the blustery day on which I conducted the comparison test, and is too minimal for me to draw any meaningful conclusions from.

Interestingly, the Remington primers produced two very nice groups and would actually have posted the smallest overall average, 0.54 inch, had it not been for one errant shot a half-inch out. It opened the average to a still-respectable 0.73 inch. Similarly, with CCI BR-4 Benchrest I had four shots in 0.41 inch but had a flier that pushed the average to 0.56 inch.

I had to wonder if the modest flier was my fault, or if it was caused by an inconsistency in the standard-grade primer. Truthfully, it could have been any number of things ranging from shooter error, handload inconsistencies or the gusting wind.

I was concerned to note that three of the 10 Remington primers were perforated by the firing pin. None of the other brands were. There was no powder residue around the perforated primers, and none of the primers in any of the test loads was flattened, so I don’t believe the perforation was a result of excessive pressure.

Rather, I’m inclined to believe the Remington primer cups are thin, and the small-diameter firing pin in the precision action simply punched through it. At any rate, promising accuracy notwithstanding, I’ll not be using Remington primers in my 6mm Creedmoor cases with Small Rifle primer pockets.

On the subject of pressure, I’ve always heard that CCI and Winchester primers have hard cups and are best for use with heavy loads. All the fired primers in the .30-06 test loads show flattening—within healthy limits— and while it’s a small sample size based on just one propellant type, one bullet type, in one caliber/case combination, I gleaned some interesting observations.

For one, the CCI Benchrest primers were the flattest of the lot, suggesting that they are no harder than the others and are perhaps softer. Most consistently shaped were the Federal primers, both match-grade and standard. Of all the primers tested, Federal’s stood out—primarily for the consistency of the velocities the cartridges primed with them produced.

Whether it’s worth it to pay the extra dinero for the Gold Medal version is up to you. I don’t think I’ll bother for working-rifle hunting ammunition.

However, my match rifle benefitted enough in velocity consistency to convince me: I’m stacking Federal Gold Medal fuses in my match ammo from now on.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Steyr Arms Announces Sniper Rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor

Steyr Arms Announces Sniper Rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor

Scott O'Brien from Steyr Arms sat down with Michael Bane at SHOT Show 2018 to take a look at Steyr's new tactical heavy barrel sniper rifle in 6.5mm Creedmoor.

Mossberg Patriot Predator 6.5 PRC Revew

Mossberg Patriot Predator 6.5 PRC Revew

Mossberg Patriot Predator 6.5 PRC Revew

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Hornady 6MM Creedmoor

Tom Beckstrand and Neal Emery of Hornady highlight the 6MM Creedmoor ammo.

RS Sako Finnlight II

RS Sako Finnlight II

The new Sako Finnlight II sports an innovative stock and Cerakote metal paired with the terrific 85 action.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Browning's new X-Bolt Max Long Range rifle is an accurate rifle tailored for long range accuracy. Bolt-Action

Browning's New X-Bolt Max Long Range Rifle

Rifle Shooter Digital Staff - April 11, 2019

Browning's new X-Bolt Max Long Range rifle is an accurate rifle tailored for long range...

Thompson/Center Arms rimfire rifles are available with Traditional Hardwood and Flat Dark Earth Black Grit finishes. Rimfire

Thompson/Center Arms Adds Stock Options to Rimfire Line

Rifle Shooter Digital Staff - April 16, 2019

Thompson/Center Arms rimfire rifles are available with Traditional Hardwood and Flat Dark...

The Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo combines high BCs with a forgiving bullet profile and promises versatile performance. Ammo

Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo

Brad Fitzpatrick - April 30, 2019

The Federal Berger Hybrid Hunter Ammo combines high BCs with a forgiving bullet profile and...

Nosler pairs its M48 action with a new Proof Research carbon-fiber barrel for a high-tech long-range rifle you can actually carry: the Nosler Model 48 Long Range Carbon. Reviews

Nosler Model 48 Long Range Carbon Review

Layne Simpson - March 13, 2019

Nosler pairs its M48 action with a new Proof Research carbon-fiber barrel for a high-tech...

See More Trending Articles

More Reloading

The handloading question: With large availability factory ammo on the market, why bother with reloading? Craig Boddington offers a few answers. Reloading

Reloading Ammo – Why?

Craig Boddington - March 26, 2019

The handloading question: With large availability factory ammo on the market, why bother with...

New reloader powders from Alliant offer improved stability in a wide range of conditions. Reloading

New Powder from Alliant with Improved Stability

Joseph von Benedikt - January 11, 2019

New reloader powders from Alliant offer improved stability in a wide range of conditions.

Here are five vastly different big game bullets that regularly provide outstanding precision and are relatively forgiving to handload. Reloading

5 Accurate Reloading Bullets for Hunting

Joseph von Benedikt - September 30, 2019

Here are five vastly different big game bullets that regularly provide outstanding precision...

Jospeh von Benedikt takes a small test to see if match-grade primers really make a difference. Reloading

Match-Grade Primers — Are They Worth It?

Joseph von Benedikt - July 21, 2020

Jospeh von Benedikt takes a small test to see if match-grade primers really make a difference.

See More Reloading

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Rifle Shooter subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now